10 Game-Changing Lessons from Decades of Short-Term Vacation Rental Investing
After three decades in the short-term vacation rental (STVR) game, I’ve seen it all—from the Wild West days of early listings to today’s tech-driven platforms. While many tips about STVR investing float around, the real difference-makers are often the less obvious strategies that elevate an ordinary rental into a profitable, passive-income powerhouse. Here are the top 10 lessons I’ve learned that can transform how you run your vacation rental business.
This isn’t just about having a clean place—it’s about creating unforgettable stays.
Smooth, Stress-Free Process: Ensure seamless booking, clear check-in instructions, and helpful local guides. A frictionless experience is key to getting 5-star reviews.
Go the Extra Mile: Think beyond basics—welcome baskets, luxury toiletries, fresh snacks, or local wine can leave a lasting impression.
Personal Touches Matter: Learn what brings your guests to town. A honeymoon couple? Leave a celebratory note and a bottle of champagne.
Lightning-Fast Responses: Being prompt and accommodating builds trust—and earns you better reviews. This has been my number one driver of 5-star reviews because it is so rare in the SRVR world.
Focus on Reviews: Prioritize delivering a memorable experience to generate glowing reviews that boost your listing’s visibility. This can mean asking kindly multiple times as most people forget and don’t realize the significance.
Based on industry insights and guest feedback, here are five investments that can make your STVR stand out:
High-Quality Bedding and Comfortable Mattresses
Guests consistently value a good night's sleep. Investing in premium mattresses and soft, quality linens can significantly enhance comfort and satisfaction.
Fully Equipped Kitchen with Complimentary Essentials
Providing a kitchen stocked with quality cookware, utensils, and basic cooking essentials like tea, coffee, sugar, salt, spices, and cooking oils allows guests to prepare meals conveniently, adding to their overall experience.
High-Speed Wi-Fi and Smart Entertainment Options
Reliable high-speed internet and smart TVs with access to streaming services are highly sought after, especially by guests combining work and leisure during their stay.
Private Outdoor Spaces with Amenities
Offering private outdoor areas equipped with seating, grills, or fire pits provides guests with additional relaxation spaces, enhancing their overall experience.
Enhanced Security Features
Installing smart locks and security systems not only ensures guest safety but also provides them with peace of mind, contributing to a more comfortable stay.
You can’t sell a secret. Your listing is your storefront—make it shine.
High-Quality Photography: Invest in professional shots that highlight your rental’s best angles. Lighting and staging matter. It is definitely worth the investment!
Write to Entice: Go beyond square footage. Paint a picture of the experience—sunset views, cozy nooks, nearby cafes and experiences.
List All Amenities: From board games to beach towels—list everything. Guests scan for convenience, and little things make a big difference.
Leverage Multiple Platforms: Airbnb, VRBO, Booking.com—diversify to maximize visibility. This can be daunting to maintain, so experiment with what works in the area you are marketing in.
Pre-Booking Messaging: Automated but warm pre-booking notes can reassure potential guests. I have a saved template that goes out to each guest when they book and days before they arrive with an alarm set so that I don’t leave guests wondering or worrying.
Daily Calendar Updates: Prevent double bookings and boost your platform rankings with accurate availability.
You’re in the hospitality business—treat it that way.
Impeccable Standards: Cleanliness is a top reason for negative reviews—don’t cut corners with cleaners and be sure to schedule regular deep cleaning.
Smart Security: Doorbell cams, motion sensors, and smart locks keep guests feeling safe and keep you informed.
Sustainable Systems: Energy-efficient lighting, smart thermostats, and water-saving features reduce long-term costs and appeal to eco-conscious travelers. Many travelers don’t have any regard for energy use so it is worth the investment to have smart devices so that you can lock and unlock the doors and control the temperature when there is no one there.
Your property should stand out before guests ever arrive.
Social Media Savvy: Showcase your rental with reels, stories, and behind-the-scenes shots. Tag local hotspots and events to engage your audience.
Loyalty Incentives: Offer repeat and longer term guests a discount or exclusive bonus—turn one-time visitors into regulars. This encourages people who are more likely to treat your property well and reduces the wear and tear that comes with high turn over rates.
Ask for Reviews (The Right Way): A well-timed message post-stay thanking guests and gently encouraging a review works wonders. Often times I do have to ask a few times as people get busy and forget.
Don’t let a technicality shut your business down.
Licensing First: Most cities require permits and fees. Stay ahead of the curve by understanding local laws before making a purchase.
Stay Regulatory Savvy: Laws change—subscribe to city updates or join local host networks.
Get Insured: Protect your asset with specialized short-term rental insurance. It’s not optional. This has saved me in the past with flooding issues.
Stay on Top of Rental Taxes: Most areas have occupancy and excise taxes specific to short term rentals. Make sure to stay up-to-date on the percentage and timing of when they are due. I learned this the hard way as the timing is dependant on the amount of income and you are expected to know this without being notified.
Understand Your Costs: Know your break-even point. Factor in fixed and variable costs—mortgage, taxes, Wi-Fi, utilities, maintenance, supplies, and platform fees.
Remote control only works when someone’s on the ground.
Reliable Cleaners & Handymen: Build relationships with pros who treat your property like their own. It is worth it to pay more for reliable quality work!
Local Co-Host or Manager: A trusted partner nearby can handle emergencies and guest needs quickly. This can often be your cleaner or handyman but it is worth paying someone to be available for emergencies.
Guests are looking for a vibe, not just a place to crash.
Creating a brand for your short-term vacation rentals—complete with a logo, consistent tone, and cohesive aesthetic—offers a powerful edge in a crowded market. A strong brand builds recognition and trust, making your listings more memorable and professional, which can boost bookings and command higher nightly rates. It also creates a sense of consistency and emotional value that guests associate with boutique hotels, encouraging loyalty and repeat stays—especially if you manage multiple properties. Branding also simplifies marketing across social media, websites, and email, driving direct bookings and reducing reliance on third-party platforms. Ultimately, a clear brand sets expectations, and enhances the guest experience.
Consider a name for your rental or rental business that guests remember and recommend.
Provide a digital guestbook or local guide with personalized recommendations to deepen their connection to your space.
Listen to the numbers. Let data guide decisions.
Use tools like AirDNA to track trends, seasonal demand, and pricing strategies.
Watch your occupancy rates, nightly rates, and guest acquisition costs to make informed tweaks.
The best-performing properties are always evolving.
Regular updates to décor, furniture, or outdoor spaces keep your listing fresh.
Add high-value amenities—hot tubs, fire pits, EV chargers—to stand out in crowded markets.
Even the best-run rentals hit bumps. Be ready.
Keep a financial buffer for lean seasons, sudden repairs, or unexpected regulatory changes.
Diversify locations as much as possible to hedge against local volatility.
Donate stays during slow times for additional tax benefits, to increase word-of-mouth clientele and help out causes that you believe in.
Lastly here are some easy, low-cost touches that make a short-term vacation rental more memorable—and that guests consistently love and remember:
Personalized Welcome Notes
A handwritten or printed card welcoming guests by name and thanking them for choosing your property sets a warm tone right away.
Complimentary Snacks or Local Treats
A small basket with chips, chocolate, granola bars, or a few locally made goodies makes guests feel immediately cared for.
A Well-Curated Local Guidebook
Include your favorite restaurants, cafes, hiking spots, or unique local experiences. Personal recommendations feel more genuine than a Google search.
Phone Chargers and Tech Extras
Guests forget chargers all the time—having extras on hand (USB-C, Lightning, etc.) is a lifesaver. Bonus: Smart speakers or white noise machines.
Cozy Extras
Things like a plush throw blanket, board games, candles, or a basket of books or magazines create a cozy, home-away-from-home vibe.
Coffee, Tea, and a Few Essentials
Offering coffee pods, a variety of teas, sugar, creamer, and filtered water makes mornings easier and more enjoyable.
Seasonal Touches or Decor
A touch of fall décor, holiday lights, or fresh flowers can make the space feel timely and thoughtful.
Umbrella or Beach Gear
Providing items like an umbrella, beach towels, or chairs (if applicable) shows you thought of everything.
Easy Self-Check-In and Clear Instructions
Seamless check-in with a friendly tone in your instructions helps guests feel relaxed before they even walk in the door.
Follow-Up Message After Check-In
A quick message asking if they need anything shortly after arrival shows attentiveness and helps resolve any small issues before they escalate.
Short-term vacation rentals aren’t just about having a pretty place—they’re about creating an experience people will pay for again and again. By combining a guest-first mindset with savvy business practices, your STVR can go from a side hustle to a scalable, sustainable income stream.
Here are the top 10 lessons I’ve learned that can transform how you run your vacation rental business.
East Shore – Market Overview
A major legal decision has overturned South Lake Tahoe’s short-term rental ban.
Get In Touch
