Short-Term vs. Long-Term Rentals: Weighing the Pros and Cons
Investing in rental properties can be a great way to build long-term wealth, but it’s important to choose the strategy that aligns with your lifestyle and goals. Some investors are drawn to the flexibility and higher income potential of short-term rentals (STRs) on platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo. Others prefer the steady cash flow and lower day-to-day involvement that long-term rentals (LTRs) can offer. Both paths have their advantages—it all comes down to your comfort level with vacancy risk and management involvement.
With over 30 years of experience in both short- and long-term leasing, I’ve seen firsthand how the rental landscape has evolved. Below, I outline the pros and cons of each strategy and offer expert insights to help you make an informed decision.
STRs are properties rented out on a nightly or weekly basis, primarily catering to vacationers, business travelers, and remote workers. In Douglas County, any rental under 28 days is considered short-term.
Pros of Short-Term Rentals
Higher Income Potential – STRs often generate more revenue per month than long-term leases. During peak seasons, nightly rates can be two to three times higher than standard monthly rent.
Flexibility – Owners can use the property for personal stays, adjust pricing based on demand, and temporarily remove it from the market if needed.
Tax Advantages – STRs may offer deductions for furnishings, utilities, and cleaning expenses, boosting profitability.
Market Adaptability – Dynamic pricing allows you to adjust rates based on seasonality, local events, and market trends.
Cons of Short-Term Rentals
Inconsistent Occupancy – Seasonal fluctuations can make cash flow unpredictable.
Higher Operating Costs – Cleaning, utilities, insurance, and regular maintenance can significantly impact profits.
Stricter Regulations – Many cities enforce zoning laws, permits, and STR restrictions, which may limit your options.
Increased Management Needs – Managing bookings, guest communications, and maintenance is time-consuming. The industry average for property management is 20–30%, which can be worth it if you prefer a hands-off approach.
Expert Tip: Build a loyal guest base by delivering an exceptional experience. Offer discounts for longer stays, partner with local businesses for exclusive perks, and monitor market trends for pricing strategies. (We’ll dive deeper into this in an upcoming article.)
LTRs are typically leased for 30 days or more. In Douglas County, rentals 28 days or longer don’t require a short-term rental permit. While they may not provide the immediate returns of STRs, they offer reliable income with fewer daily demands.
Pros of Long-Term Rentals
Steady, Predictable Income – Fixed leases provide reliable monthly cash flow.
Lower Turnover & Management Needs – Less frequent cleaning and guest coordination compared to STRs.
Fewer Operating Costs – Tenants often pay for utilities and basic upkeep.
Less Regulatory Risk – LTRs face fewer zoning and licensing challenges.
Long-Term Equity Growth – With tenants covering much of the property's carrying cost, you can steadily build wealth with minimal hands-on involvement.
Cons of Long-Term Rentals
Limited Pricing Flexibility – Lease terms lock in rates, making it harder to respond to market shifts.
Less Control Over Property – Tenant behavior is harder to monitor, and evictions can be lengthy and expensive.
Slower Income Growth – Rent control or local caps can limit annual increases.
Tenant Non-Compliance – In some states (e.g., California, Hawaii), evicting non-paying tenants can be a legal challenge. Nevada, however, offers a more streamlined process for resolving such issues.
Expert Tip: Want stability with more income? Mid-term rentals (30–90 days) are ideal for traveling nurses, remote workers, or families in transition. Platforms like Furnished Finder, Landing, and Airbnb’s monthly-stay feature cater to this growing niche—often skirting STR regulations and hotel tax rules.
Bonus Insight: Regardless of lease type, thorough tenant screening is essential. Verify employment, run credit/background checks, and call prior landlords. A great tenant can mean years of smooth operations, while a bad one can cost thousands.
Location Matters
Tourist hot spots (e.g., Tahoe, Hawaii): STRs yield high income but come with high property costs.
Suburban or family-friendly areas: LTRs offer more consistent demand and lower costs.
Financial Goals
Seeking steady income? LTRs are more predictable.
Open to higher effort for higher return? STRs may pay off.
Time Commitment
Want passive income? LTRs are less demanding.
Like running a business? STRs can be very rewarding with hands-on management.
If you go the STR route, use these tactics to maximize profit and reduce risk:
Automate Operations – Tools like Hospitable and Guesty streamline bookings and guest communication.
Use Dynamic Pricing – Software like PriceLabs or Beyond Pricing ensures competitive rates.
Invest in Quality Cleaning & Maintenance – Quick turnovers and routine upkeep prevent costly issues.
Optimize Your Listing – Professional photos and engaging copy boost visibility.
Screen Guests & Set Boundaries – Require IDs, deposits, and consider noise monitoring tools like Minut or NoiseAware.
Know the Laws – Stay compliant with zoning, licensing, and tax regulations.
Expert Tip: Treat your STR like a boutique hotel. Add personal touches—welcome baskets, local guides, thoughtful amenities—and prioritize guest experience. That’s how you earn five-star reviews and repeat bookings. (We’ll dive deeper into this in two weeks.)
There’s no universal answer—each strategy has its strengths. Your decision should reflect your risk tolerance, location, and long-term goals.
Want higher income and are comfortable with variability? STRs are a great fit.
Prefer reliable returns and less hassle? LTRs are your best bet.
With over 30 years in this space, I’ve seen markets shift, regulations evolve, and investor strategies transform. The key to success? Stay adaptable. Market trends, local laws, and guest expectations will continue to change—and the best investors change with them.
Coming Soon: “10 Game-Changing Lessons from Decades of STR Investing.” I learned these lessons the hard way—but you don’t have to. I’ll share how I consistently earned five-star reviews and maintained Superhost status on major platforms.
Ready to get started—or refine your rental strategy? Let’s connect and find the best approach for your goals.
East Shore – Market Overview
A major legal decision has overturned South Lake Tahoe’s short-term rental ban.
Get In Touch
